What is the difference between justified and unjustified criticism?
Valid criticism contains evidence and arguments that support its correctness. It is based on facts and logic and is aimed at improving the situation or product.
Phrases such as
“Everything is fine, and I noticed that this version can be improved and here’s why…”
“I see you’ve been working hard on this project, and I have some ideas. Let’s try running through them together?”
“Can I share my experience with you? I think it will help foresee some things.”
The best formula for respond to giving feedback to a person is balanced feedback. The idea is that you first highlight the positive aspects of the idea, and then say what could be improved and how it will affect the result. We do not use “but” in principle. Try to always replace the phrase “yes, but” with “yes, and”.
Unfounded criticism, on the other betting database hand, has no evidence or arguments. It may be based on personal prejudices, stereotypes, or simply emotional reactions. Such criticism does not help improve the situation, but only creates conflicts and disagreements.
The IKRA School of Creative
Thinking and Innovation collaborates with freelance designers, understanding how important it is for many of them to create products that reflect their personal style. If we had to turn to a designer who insisted on preserving his or her “signature,” most likely, he or she would not suit us, because we value the ability to adhere to our corporate style. If the designer sent a finished product, he or she could face unfounded criticism. To avoid this, we always carefully discuss the terms and clarify the details in advance.
Or, for example, if you the complete guide to link building in western europe respond to are a manager who is consistently late for a Monday aero leads meeting, you may find yourself in a situation where your boss calls you in to discuss your work requirements. In this situation, your boss’s criticism of you would be justified.
It’s good if you respond to encounter justified criticism that follows all the rules of effective communication. But what about unjustified criticism?